Salty snacks + soda = obese children
-
- March
- 5
Rafael’s favorite new snack is the Goldfish crackers made from pretzels. I’d say it’s Markus’ favorite, too, but he eats most things with the same gusto, so it’s kinda hard to tell.
So when I was perusing the web last week for blog fodder (there’s only so long I can expect anyone to read entries entitled “I like meat.” and “The taste of toothpaste.” Which, speaking of, we went back to the old blue-colored Oral-B Disney Cars toothpaste over the weekend instead of the red-and-white Aquafresh Dr. Seuss toothpaste and Rafael was quite pleased. “It doesn’t taste like sour pickle!” he joyfully declared.) and I stumbled upon this article by the Associated Press. The premise was, “Kids who load up on salty meals and snacks get thirsty, and too often they turn to calorie-filled sodas.”
Apparently, a British study published recently in an American Heart Association journal determined this stunning fact. (Please read the end of that sentence with appropriate sarcasm.)
I mean, if your child is drinking lots of soda, that’s going to translate into fat on their little bodies. If you don’t realize that, I can’t help you.
The study was based on diet data from Great Britain’s National Diet and Nutrition Survey. Researchers looked at 1,688 British boys and girls  ages 4 to 18  over a seven-day period in 1997.They noted that the amount of salt eaten might be underestimated in the study because it did not include salt added during cooking or at the table. The researchers also found that more than half the fluids drunk by the children were soft drinks, and more than half of those were sugar-sweetened.
I’d wager that if that study had been done in the States, the amount of sugar-sweetened drinks would have been far greater. This country, after all, sometimes appears to be built entirely on corn syrup (the fuel crisis may actually help resolve that issue due to the push to use corn for ethanol, making it too precious to waste on a mere sweetener).
I by no means hold myself out to be the perfect parent; I’ve used chocolate as a bribe with my sons and I make no bones about it. And if, for one meal, Rafael wants crackers or bread with butter, fine. We just make sure he gets protein and other important nutrients in other ways during other meals. But we don’t let them drink soda.
First off, why on earth would I give my already (very) active pre-schooler and toddler sugar and/or caffeine?
We try not to drink soda much around them, but it is, I admit (head hung in shame) one of those do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do things. I mostly drink diet soda, but I don’t want them ingesting all those chemicals while their brains are still forming. It’s too late for me, but I’d like to try to avoid turning my boys into chemical dumps. And the un-diet sodas are filled with so many empty calories that I even get annoyed at Daddy when he occasionally has one.
Still, to me, the issue is not merely whether your children are eating too many salty snacks or drinking copious sugary beverages or munching on enough carrots. The issue is simple. And it is this: Are you paying attention to what your child eats? Do you make sure that over the course of a week, she is eating enough of what he or she needs and not too much of what he doesn’t?
I just know that when Rafael and Markus get thirsty from eating pretzel Goldfish, the only beverages they get to sate their thirst is water, apple juice or milk (OK, Rafael sometimes asks for seltzer, which does make him belch, but that makes both of them very happy).
Sure, food manufacturers do seem to put too much sodium in processed foods. And it is hard, sometimes to feed what really seems like a balanced, nutritious meal that’s also affordable, to your children. Especially when your son eats two spoons of oatmeal (Rafael, this morning) and declares he ate ALL his oatmeal and he’s very full now, thank you very much. Then decides he wants a yogurt and comes into the kitchen after EVERY spoonful to inform me he’s just eaten ANOTHER spoonful! (I, of course, mustered all the enthusiasm I had an exclaimed, “THAT’S GREAT! Now go eat another spoonful.”)
But, when it comes down to it, we are their parents. We can’t go around blaming the food manufacturers for all our children’s (or our own, for that matter) weight problems.
Like this doctor says, Parents are, indeed, often the “weakest link in the childhood obesity epidemic.” (By the by, here’s a pdf of a summary of the report by the Institute of Medicine about childhood obesity that the doctor in the previous link references.)
In good news, though, apparently the FDA “is taking public comment until March 28 on a consumer group’s proposal to restrict the amount of salt in processed foods, among other options,” according to that AP article. An expert in the article said parents should feed their children more fresh fruits and veggies, but don’t add salt. If anyone has any bright ideas on how to get Rafael to eat fruits other than grapes or apples or veggies other than carrots, please call me.
But to prove that I’m not totally without quality info: Check out this recent guide to proper toddler portions in USA Today.
Photo by Joe Larese/The Journal News, 1998






















I applaud you for not wanting to turn your boys into “chemical dumps.” It is appalling how soda has turned into a standard beverage. Your link on toddler proportions got me thinking about calorie needs for my own two boys. The AHA (http://www.americanheart.org/presenter.jhtml?identifier=3033999) lists a table, but what really stunned me was their footnote that said they based their calorie estimates on a “sedentary lifestyle.” Is that the norm now? Sad, sad, sad.
For the same reasons, my partner and I have worked for 5 long years to bring our new line of potato chips to the market. they are called “Power Potato Chips” and are enhanced with High and Good sources of vitamins and mineral. They have honest and real benefits. Check out our website. http://www.powerfoodproduct.com and make sure you order some.
Instead of focusing on fat and size on children, we need to be focusing on healthy habits. As you point out, it is not good for children to be eating that much sugar and soda, but I have seen rail skinny kids with the same habits described. There is a new study that obesity in children is 77% genetics, and there have been a lot of other supporting studies. As the parent of two obese children who are active and eat well, it is a constant struggle to maintain a healthy body image in today’s society. They are immediately judged as unhealthy and as having poor habits from their size alone (as I am). It is not that I don’t believe that there is a portion of society that would change size if they altered their habits. I just think it is far more useful to concentrate on promoting health, and not tying size, which is something that can be uncontrollable except through extreme measures, with health. What happens when someone changes their diet expecting to lose weight and it doesn’t go away? Often they give up. If they approached the changes with an eye on a healthy lifestyle, there might be a pleasant surprise of weight loss, but no weight loss would not affect the motivation for the changes.
OK- sorry for the rant, but it is an issue close to my heart and something we deal with on a daily basis.
That’s a good point, Krista. Some people are dealing with genetics, and not habits. I think there’s a need to consider all points on these issues. My main problem is when people throw up their hands and bemoan their children’s eating and TV-watching habits, but then turn on the TV and feed them nothing but McDonald’s, you know?
I do think it’s important, though, for people not to pass immediate judgments and make assumptions based on little to no knowledge, and it sounds as if that’s what happens to you and your children.
As someone who’s trying hard to lose all the baby weight I gained each time (I’m nearly back down to the weight I was between babies, never mind to where I was before my first, when I needed to lose weight anyhow!) and trust me, I know how hard it can be to lose weight; and how judgmental people can be about it.
Hope you come back and visit soon, we’d love to hear your thoughts anytime!